"A book, too, can be a star, 'explosive material, capable of stirring up fresh life endlessly,' a living fire to lighten the darkness, leading out into the expanding universe." - from Madeleine L'Engle's Newberry Medal Acceptance Speech

Monday, September 24, 2012

Class notes on writing reading responses


812
Qualities of Awesome Reading Responses
Topics to write reading responses about:

·         Examples from text – quotations
·         Not too much summary – leave some room for curiosity
·         Summary should help you visualize and understand background of story
·         Self-to-text comparison
·         Writer’s opinion
·         Informative details
·         Get into the characters’ minds
·         Show all characters’ emotions and point of views
·         Explain setting
·         Making inferences that are interesting
·         Opposing ideas or viewpoints
·         Think outside the box
·         Make it interesting and engaging for the readers – audience; write about books that peers like
·         Writing: focus on 1 main idea – don’t wander off – tie ideas together
·         Process: have post-its/notes throughout your book, think about main idea, jot down notes/quotations, questioning, brief outline


·         Compare/contrast: character at beginning and end; 2 different characters; 2 different books; connect book to film; yourself and character;
·         Analyzing foreshadowing and connecting to future events in the text
·         Character: how they are influenced by another character or event, inner feelings, intentions/actions – are they morally good?, relationships, what would you do in their situation, archetypes
·         Symbolism, metaphor, simile
·         Unusual format/structure: ex. Letter format, poetry, etc.
·         Setting
·         Meaningful parts such as the climax/turning point
·         Begin with a thought-provoking question – why/how


807

Qualities of really good reading responses:
Topics to write reading responses about:
  • Include your own voice – what you thought of the book; make it unique to you; include opinions
  • Polished writing – sentences, grammar, spelling are correct
  • Have a clear thesis – main idea/opinion; focus on thesis
  • Semi-summary – include just brief summary/context for reader; don’t just summarize
  • Examples from text/Include quotations and explain quotations afterward
  • Relative details about the story
  • 3 or more paragraphs
  • In the beginning: state title and author and thesis
  • Have a clear, accurate, deep understanding of the text
  • State a theme and explain it: lessons
  • Include predictions and explain
  • Characters: problems, change, how they solve their problems, emotions, lessons they learned, how they affect other characters, hero’s journey, protagonist and antagonist, personal connections, archetypes  
  • Setting
  • Plot mountain
  • Compare/contrast with another text or your life
  • What you liked/didn’t like about particular aspect of text such as style, character,etc
  • Symbols, signs, metaphor/simile
  • Process: keep going back to the book, brainstorm – chart, web, list quotations, etc., write summary, take notes as you read – post-its or in the book or in nb; make sure you edit and proofread


811

Qualities of really good reading responses:
Topics to write reading responses on:
  • Vivid, relevant ideas that provide reader with a broad understanding of text
  • Specific opinion/thought about the book that writer focuses on
  • Clearly expressed opinions and thoughts
  • Strong personal connections
  • Specific point or main idea to communicate that is backed up/supported
  • The right balance of summary and background while still making the reader want to read the book – setting, character
  • Highlight important parts of the text
  • Include quotations/evidence and explain how they relate
  • Go deeply into character
  • Writing is specific, thorough
  • Write with your own voice; include your own opinions; make sure it is interesting and engaging for your audience
  • Write a conclusion that sums up main ideas/thoughts
  • Structure – organize your ideas into paragraphs
  • Before you publish – write an outline, drafts, revise, edit
  • Character – conflict, opinions about them, what you like/dislike about them, how they’re unique, how they change, struggle, archetypes
  • Main purpose or theme of text, lessons
  • Personal reaction
  • How the text relates to another text or the real world or your self
  • Metaphor, symbolism

No comments:

Post a Comment